EXR not being saved with full dynamic range

[face_off]

Here is a test release with the saving of EXR's from the "Save" and "Save All Render Passes" being done with the linear colorspace rather than sRGB. Let me know if you have any issues with this build.

https://render.otoy.com/customerdownloa ... _test1.exe

Thanks

Paul

[Dingbat]

thanks Paul

had a go with this but there are still issues

the image seems to be saved linear, but max white values are clipped at 1.0 (they should go beyond 1.0)

also, tonemapping is saved. with linear workflow the image should be saved without tonemapping (unless Force Tonemapping is selected)

[face_off]

I think I have messed this feature request up - as there is a conflict between the new combobox and the Settings->Image Save Format. If you set the Image Save Format to EXR, does that resolve the problem?

Paul

[Dingbat]

i reverted back to the old version so not sure, but i didn't know there was an option to change the image format

i always just use the 'Save All Render Passes' button and the only option there is to save as EXR

if i use the 'Save' button the only option is to save as PNG (and it will only save 1 pass)

also, i'm not using F9 render, i'm rendering from the Octane Render Setup Window - Open Window (rendering in the OctaneRender Viewport)

[Dingbat]

i just tried an f9 render (with the official version, not the test version) and when saving the image there is no option to save as EXR (which must be why i render in the OctaneRender Viewport)

i can't reinstall the test version right now but could have a go this weekend if useful - let me know

[face_off]

I am just getting back to this issue after doing the AC27 version. Looking at the various image save points:

1) PhotoRender Projection (with the OctaneRender Renderer engine selected) -> ArchiCAD controls the saving, and I assume that only 8bit saving is possible
2) Progressive Saving - doubt anyone uses this anymore. The FORMAT that is saved is specified in the Configuration->Image Save Format combobox
3) The "Save" button on the Octane "Rendering" tab. This is where it gets complex. The Octane SDK allows a "save format" (which is 8-bit PNG, 16-bit PNG, 16-bit EXR or 32-bit EXR) which is different from the filename extension. The "save format" is specified in the Configuration->Image Save Format combobox. So users need to match the file extension they save to with the Save Format in the Configuration. The "Color Space" saved will be Linear if the file extension is EXR, or sRGB if the extension is EXR.
4) The "Save All Render Passes" button on the Octane "Rendering" tab. This will assume you are saving to EXR with Linear color space, either 16 or 32 bit (as per the combobox).

So with this in mind, can you indicate specifically which of the above are not saving correctly?

And yes, I need to fix 3) so that you don't need to go into the Configuration to change the Save Format when saving. Perhaps EXR is not needed as an option when saving via 3?

Thanks

Paul

[Dingbat]

sorry Paul have been using MODO/Octane for rendering lately so missed this

i use option 4 to save multi layer renders and it seems to be working as expected - 16bit EXR has all the DR i need

[face_off]

Thanks for the feedback. I am now assuming there is no more work needed on this issue.

Paul

[Dingbat]

Thanks for the feedback. I am now assuming there is no more work needed on this issue.

Paul

sorry for the late reply

yes thank you. afaic this is working correctly now