So this is my result from last night. I haven't had a chance to implement the suggestions that you guys have mentioned. I just cranked up the samples, and then I used Neat Video's noise reduction tool, and magic bullet looks to finish off the look and get a little more chromic abb, glow, star, and curves.
Things I'll try tonight (for my own reference later)
1) Double Dimensions
2) Lower max samples to 500-600
3) Set filter size to 1
4) Neat video noise removal (I do this in AE not PS because I want to animate eventually)
5) Look up caustic blur
6) Try PMC Kernel instead of Direct Lighting Diffuse
Thanks for all your help!