dimdedi wrote:The problem is that is it worth buying this plugin considering the dark future of Carrara? Is it better to rather invest in the plugin for DAZ Studio as this program will certainly continue to be developed by DAZ? Nevertheless you have done an excellent job for Carrara. In these conditions, it is difficult for me to make my choice.
This might be off-topic for this thread, and maybe the discussion should be moved elsewhere, but I have a few observations and opinions about the direction of Carrara and DAZ Studio. I own both Octane plugins, and I've been trying to decide what direction to move with an Octane production pipe. In the next week or so I'll be fleshing out Carrara's potential.
I use Carrara because of the thoughtful, intuitive, no-nonsense interface. Most of the bugs have work-arounds and the powerful features outweigh the bugs for my uses.
I was a bit surprised and encouraged to find that DAZ had quietly released Carrara Pro 8.5.1 and to read on the boards that they are working on support for Genesis 3. Hopefully there will be more bug fixes and restoration of some of what's been lost and injured along the way, such as duplicating figures, (quick) incremental saving, and sane keyframe behavior.
Octane and Genesis support have both made Carrara more future worthy.
Personally, I'm hoping that DAZ pulled promotion of Carrara from their site to prevent nullification of the brand from an shamefully buggy release. Hopefully ahead of a (planned) stronger future release.
But I don't understand the technical difficulty of fixing the obvious bugs and potholes. It seems like this would be simpler than the time they're having of it. I wonder if I'm being naive to just assume this will happen.
It seems that the DAZ dev team has been focusing a lot of effort on integrating their new render engine. It's nice to have options, but also kinda sad considering the more fundamental issues that need addressing. It also seems like a questionable strategy for DAZ to have done this considering the wide industry support for Octane. Since their market is primarily content sales, wouldn't being more compatible help on that account?
In any case, I wish DAZ all the best with whatever improvements they choose to make to either platform. Maybe DAZ can coax Sighman into helping them with Carrara development.
Thanks again,
-John