Help with choosing software

Discuss anything you like on this forum.
Post Reply
User avatar
jagger
Licensed Customer
Posts: 251
Joined: Fri May 14, 2010 6:32 pm
Location: Spain

Hi, first this is not a vs app question. Im trying to find the best tool for what I want to do and something wich I feel comfortable.

Im specialising in doing stills. Im a compositor working in cgi animated films but as I will leave this market I would like to jump in the field of photorealistic stills(advertising?).

This two studios are the best examples of what I want to be:

http://www.lightfarmstudios.com/
http://www.christophehuet.com/#/ALL

I THINK that the best alternatives are:

- c4d: basically, this is the platform that receives all the stuff and render it. Of course for hard surface modeling, texturing, lighting etc..

- zbrush: the only real choice for sculpt.

- mari: the best tool for texturing, also the one with brightest future.(maybe its too much? maybe can do this in ps?)

- octane: because, its fast, photorealistic and easy to use.

- photoshop: Maybe the most important of all. As compositor I can boost the quality of the image in this stage (compared to my knowledge in modeling/texturing).

WHAT I miss?
-more vfx stuff... c4d lacks a lot in that field. Xparticles is not so "pro" compared to pflow for example. Turbulence is not Fumefx. Nitroblast is not Rayfire etc..
-decent scatter tool: I have carbon scatter 2 for c4d but its not very stable. Replicators in Modo are sooo cool.
-c4d nodal texturing, decent uvs.

SO the big thing out there is Maya, with lot of features and 3rd party implementations that are soo cool like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=p ... AWPE-4Eb8s

Also Modo is nice, but outside from model, uv and retopo its very convoluted. I prefer c4d.

THEN maybe the best and smarter alternative is Maya+arnold/octane/vray3. But maybe Maya is too overwhelming for the things I want to do. Maybe c4d/octane are enough solution...

Here you can see some of my works: http://www.octavioalonso.com

Please tell me what do you think (forgive my english! :? )
intel i7 3770k // 2 x Evga Titan Superclocked 6gb Vram // 16gb RAM
http://www.octavioalonso.com
User avatar
00Ghz
Licensed Customer
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Sep 13, 2013 6:54 am
Location: Denmark
Contact:

Do you care about prices?

Mari and PS are 2 different things. Want pro stuff go Mari if you can afford it. Or try Substance Painter.

C4D modeling is not that great.

I would suggest you go Modo + Mari. Convoluted? :D Use Zbrush and Blender first and Modo's UI would become amazing.

However C4D has better plugin support. It is a hard choice.
HDRI Editor for Blender : Your own HDRI Studio at an affordable price.

https://gum.co/HDRIEditor
Post Reply

Return to “Off Topic Forum”