OTOY Forums

Hi,
I have a simple plane on wish I scatter a meshes (7000 faces) using particle flow.
Each time I set particle birth to more than 1500 instances Max crashes when opening OctaneRender viewport (or launching a render).

I think 1500 instance is not a big deal for particle...I would need 10 000 + instances in this scene...

Is it a memory issue?
Is there a way to instance the meshe?

Fabrice

Hi Fabrice,
I noticed delays or lacks with Pflow, but not crashes.
Could you kindly share the file (in private if you want) to check your issue?
Regards
Paride

Sorry for posting so late, I was off for a few days.
Here's a scene.
A simple Pflow scattering teapot on a plane.
It renders with Birth set to 2000.
If I raise the birth to 3000 it crashes.

Seems to be a memory issue...
_________
24 Gb ram on a dual E5-2630 xeon + Win7pro SP1.
2 GPUs : GTX 980 ti + GTX 780

PS I tried desactivating the GTX 780 GPU but it still crashes

Hi Fabrice,
I made some test with your scene, I think your crash depends on memory.
Lags persist and increase with increasing instances, but I did not crash; I had a long lag freezing at about 6,000.
I've reported this issue to developers earlier, but I'll add your test too.
Regards
Paride

Can you tell me what you mean by "depends on memory"?

Bad memory on PC? on GPU ?
Insufficient amount of GPU memory?

Fabrice

HI Fabrice,
VRam I mean.
If you are using GTX 980Ti and GTX 780 together, your total Vram avaible (in Octane) is 3GB.
If you are using GTX 780 only for OS, monitor etc.. and GTX 980 in Octane, your total Vram (in Octane) is 6GB.
Certainly Ram could be a cause, but you can check it in Windows task manager by checking how much RAM is available by increasing the istance.
Having said that, using many many instances, 3dsMax Viewport suffers (lags) with GTX 780 to display your scene, regardless of Octane render, you can find it in scanline too.
I think there is an issue between Pflow and Octane, because Forest pack seems to work better with istance, does not lags or creates freezing.
Regards
Paride

When redering with 3000 particle, the task manager indicates that Ram stays under 20 Go usage over 24 Go total.
So it's not a Ram limit problem I guess.

Also what is strange is that the octane viewport indicates 4.794 Go available VRam.
Shouldn't it be 6 Go available as only the GTX980ti is active?

Hi Fabrice,
I meant Ram limit problems, about 3dsMax lag,
If your task manager indicates 20GB Ram usage during render phase, then in Voxelization Phase, your system will go to paging with heavily lags.
Increasing the istance, crash is increasingly likely.
Around 4.794 GB, is your monitor/s connected to gtx 980ti?
I suppose you did.
Connects it to gtx780.
Is your pc running under window 10?
Regards
Paride

Yes 1 of the 2 monitors is connected to the 980ti, you think that's what take 1.206 Go away?
I run Win7pro

Regards,
Fabrice

Hi Fabrice,
Connect both monitors to Gtx 780, you will have full 6Gb and Gtx 980ti power available under Octane.
Windows 7 is better than windows 10.
Regards
Paride